Sunday, January 29, 2006

A Quote

So I was re-reading some of Shiller's book Irrational Exuberance today. I was interested in the chapter (chapter 11 - "Investor Learning and Unlearning") where he discusses the possibility that the stock market has only recently become a rational market due to the general investing public having recently learned some "facts" about the market. For example, leading up to the pop of the stock market bull run of the late 90's people had learned such "facts" as "stocks always outperform other investments, such as bonds", "the stock market always quickly recovers after a major decline", etc., and that the reason for the huge price movements and their expected future continuation was because the market had become rational.

He concludes the chapter with this:
A similar process of investor "learning" appears also to have been going on in connection with other markets besides just the stock market. People have been "learning" that investments in homes are really not risky, that homes are the "best" investment. The perception that the public has just learned some important facts lends support to massive market price increases by encouraging the belief that these increases may be permanent.

The sense that we are all suddenly learning important facts and have arrived at a new enlightenment about investment has appeared so many times in history that it may be regarded as a predictable component of irrational exuberance. We must consider how to deal with the change in thinking that leads people to think we have entered a new enlightenment, changes that, through their effects on market prices, impinge on all our lives.

We have to consider what we as individuals and as a society should be doing to offset some of the ill effects of this exuberance.

pp. 202-3
The next section is appropriately entitled "A Call to Action".

4 comments:

Marinite said...

I don't have the book, but someone told me that he shows that the long run real rate of return on housing is zero. In other words, in the long run, after you subtract inflation and maintenance, housing is a poor place to invest.

Yes, that is very true... he does. Housing is not a great investment in the long run. The data he presents is pretty hard to argue against.

Anonymous said...

Along the same lines as the previous post, consider that we are in the 4th year of a stock market rally where most advisors think there will be "modest" appreciation in domestic stocks this year.

Just like with housing, that sounds to me like like inaccurate perception of future risk and returns.

Something to think about when you are allocating your 401k contributions for the year...

Rob Dawg said...

The problem with housing as just an investment is that it ignores the value of living someplace for free. It may not come anywhere close to a monthly SPDR investment but you can't sleep in an index fund.

Anonymous said...

peterbob-

Numerous people (including my parents) are multimillionaires due to investing in real estate. Not sure how they accomplished it with a zero rate of return, as you claim. However, I do agree that prices are in for a flat spell.