Monday, March 27, 2006

The Commission

Why do we have a system where both the buyer's real estate agent and the seller's agent are incentivized to encourage the highest sale price possible on a house? Shouldn't the buyer's agent be incentivized to achieve the lowest possible price whereas the seller's agent is incentivized to achieve the highest possible price? Is the only viable solution to remove all commissions from all steps of the housing valuation process (loan officers, appraisers, real estate agents, etc.)? Shouldn't the commission be replaced by a flat fee that has absolutely nothing to do with the sale/asking price of a house and everything to do with the actual amount of work the agent does? If there were a flat fee at all points in the process of buying a house, wouldn't that allow for more competition among the various players (loan officers, appraisers, real estate agents, etc.) and thereby result in fairer pricing of houses in our free market economy? What can be done to change the way agents, etc., get paid? Should something be done?


Blogger tduccini said...

I have always thought this little arrangement did little more than encourage a little wink, wink, nudge, nudge kind of price fixing collusion.

I think a flat fee would be more appropriate and allow for those agents and brokers worth their salt to put a real value on their services.

Mar 27, 2006, 12:10:00 PM  
Blogger fredtobik said...

It would be nice, but taking money from people is hard to do. Sounds like a startup opportunity.

Mar 27, 2006, 3:50:00 PM  
Blogger Marinite said...

My hope is that if the housing bubble crashes hard and if people get hurt enough, then some good might come out of this if people then begin to seriously question NIMBYism, MALT, Prop 13, realtor (and other) commissions, etc. We could only be better off for it in the long term.

Mar 27, 2006, 5:09:00 PM  
Blogger Athena said...

I would think that the real professionals in the real estate industry would welcome a financial structure that would separate the best from the rest. Certainly their profession has attracted some opportunistic and poorly qualified people during the boom times that many long time real estate professionals say give their whole profession a bad name.

So what better way do they have for making sure only those who are truly competent get paid for it.

The way it is, those who are less qualified don't necessarily make less... the commission structure is hardly a standard for meritocracy.

Mar 27, 2006, 9:25:00 PM  
Blogger marine_explorer said...

I see a combination of factors that will drive a market towards slimmer margins:

>Public outcry over fraud and price-fixing of real estate. I imagine we'll see some well-needed regulation here. Buyers may be very skeptical towards realtors in the future, and they'll need to prove their worth.

>If the RE market collapses, there will be a surplus of realtors, possibly working for less to undercut each other.

>If an RE collapse triggers economic instability, I think all this nonsense spouting from NAR, Lereah, et al will be more closely scrutinized. And, given the recent reaction in DC to lobbyists, I see the NAR losing power to consumer advocacy.

>That legislation to open up the MLS and pave the way for online businesses may cut margins significantly for the whole industry. Good; it's about time.

Athena: I agree that those realtors who built a reputation for themselves will have a better chance surviving any future shakedown. We have a local realtor here who we completely trust, and while he's a little worried about the future, I think his reputation will keep him afloat.

Mar 28, 2006, 8:51:00 AM  
Blogger Matt Norris said...

For a real laugh, go over to Brad Inman's blog and read some comments posted about articles in the last few weeks that discuss commissions for Realtors, the MLS, etc.

Some of the statements by "professionals" in those discussions would make your jaw drop.

Mar 28, 2006, 9:29:00 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Terms of Use: The purpose of the Marin Real Estate Bubble weblog (located at URL and henceforth referred to as “MREB” or “this site”) is to present and discuss information relating to real estate and the real estate industry in general (locally, state-wide, nationally, and internationally) as it pertains to the thesis that recent real estate related activity is properly characterized as a “speculative mania” or a “bubble”. MREB is a non-profit, community site that depends on community participation and feedback. While MREB administrators do strive to confirm all information presented here and qualify all doubtful items, the information presented at MREB is neither definitive nor should it be construed as professional advice. All information published on MREB is provided “as is” without warranty of any kind and the administrators of this site shall not be liable for any direct or indirect damages arising out of use of this site. This site is moderated by MREB administrators and the MREB administrators reserve the right to edit, remove, or refuse postings that are off-topic, defamatory, libelous, offensive, or otherwise deemed inappropriate by MREB administrators. You should consult a finance professional before making any decisions based on information found on this site.

The contributors to this site may, from time to time, hold short (or long) positions in mentioned and related companies.